Charcoal pencils are a must-have for any artist looking to create rich, expressive drawings—but not all charcoal pencils are created equal! Before you invest in a set, it’s crucial to know which ones will suit your art style, techniques, and comfort level.
In this guide, I’ll break down the top 5 charcoal pencils for artists, highlighting their pros and cons so you can make an informed decision. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned pro, this list will help you find the perfect charcoal pencil for your creative needs!
🖤 What to Look for in a Charcoal Pencil
Before we dive into the best picks, here are a few key factors to consider when choosing a charcoal pencil:
✔️ Softness & Hardness – Soft charcoal offers rich, deep blacks, while harder charcoal provides more control and detail.
✔️ Blendability – Some charcoal pencils smudge beautifully for shading, while others hold their lines firmly.
✔️ Durability – Charcoal pencils tend to be fragile. Some brands break easily, while others are reinforced.
✔️ Mess Factor – Do you love the smudgy, expressive look of charcoal, or do you prefer a cleaner experience?
🖊️ Top 5 Charcoal Pencils for Artists (Pros & Cons)
1. General’s Charcoal Pencils – Best Overall
(This post contains affiliate links, meaning I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you)
⭐ Pros: Smooth application, rich blacks, great for blending
⚠️ Cons: Can be fragile, may need frequent sharpening
A favorite among artists, General’s charcoal pencils deliver deep, velvety blacks and blend beautifully. They’re perfect for shading and expressive sketches but can break easily if dropped.
👉 Best for: Artists who love rich tones and smooth blending.
🛒 Shop Here: General’s Charcoal Pencils on Amazon
2. Derwent Charcoal Pencils – Best for Detail Work
⭐ Pros: Less smudging, strong core, great for fine lines
⚠️ Cons: Not as dark as other brands, harder texture
Derwent’s charcoal pencils are firmer, making them ideal for detailed sketches and controlled shading. They produce cleaner lines with less mess, but if you’re after deep, dramatic blacks, you may find them too light.
👉 Best for: Artists who need precision and less smudging.
🛒 Shop Here: Derwent Charcoal Pencils on Amazon
3. Faber-Castell Pitt Charcoal Pencils – Best for Smoothness
⭐ Pros: Glides effortlessly, deep black color, high-quality
⚠️ Cons: Pricier than other options
Known for their ultra-smooth application, Faber-Castell Pitt charcoal pencils are a dream to work with. They’re high-quality, long-lasting, and less brittle than many other brands. The price is higher, but the performance justifies the cost!
👉 Best for: Artists who want premium quality and smooth application.
🛒 Shop Here: Faber-Castell Pitt Charcoal Pencils on Amazon
4. Conte à Paris Charcoal Pencils – Best for Rich Tones
⭐ Pros: Intense black shades, great for dramatic shading
⚠️ Cons: Can be difficult to erase
If you love bold, dramatic drawings, Conte à Paris charcoal pencils are perfect! They deliver deep, rich blacks that stand out, but they can be tricky to erase once applied.
👉 Best for: Artists who want bold, dramatic shading.
🛒 Shop Here: Conte à Paris Charcoal Pencils on Amazon
5. Primo Euro Blend Charcoal Pencils – Best for Softness
⭐ Pros: Incredibly soft, deep velvety blacks, effortless shading
⚠️ Cons: Very smudgy, can get messy
For soft, expressive strokes, Primo Euro Blend charcoal pencils are unmatched. Their buttery-smooth texture makes them great for blending and shading, but they can get messy fast.
👉 Best for: Artists who love soft, moody shading and expressive work.
🛒 Shop Here: Primo Euro Blend Charcoal Pencils on Amazon
🖌️ Final Thoughts: Which Charcoal Pencil is Right for You?
Still unsure? Here’s a quick cheat sheet:
🎨 Best Overall: General’s Charcoal Pencils
🖋 Best for Detail Work: Derwent Charcoal Pencils
✨ Best for Smoothness: Faber-Castell Pitt Charcoal Pencils
🌑 Best for Rich Tones: Conte à Paris Charcoal Pencils
🖤 Best for Softness: Primo Euro Blend Charcoal Pencils
The right charcoal pencil depends on your artistic style and personal preference. Whether you want crisp lines, deep blacks, or ultra-smooth blending, there’s a perfect option for you!
💡 Which charcoal pencil do you swear by? Drop your favorite in the comments!
📌 Pin this guide for later!
Want More?
If you loved this guide, check out:
➡️ The Best Paper for Charcoal Drawings
➡️ How to Blend Charcoal Like a Pro
[…] 5. Charcoal (Optional for Deep Shadows) […]